Mastering Performance: A Call Center Action Plan Example for Underperforming Agents

A call center action plan example serves as a vital tool for any organization aiming to boost the performance of its customer service representatives. In the dynamic world of call centers, where agents are the frontline ambassadors of your brand, their performance directly impacts customer satisfaction, operational efficiency, and ultimately, your bottom line. When agents underperform, it can lead to frustrated customers, missed targets, and a dip in team morale. This comprehensive guide outlines how to construct an effective action plan template, designed to systematically address underperformance and cultivate a thriving, high-achieving team.

Analyze & Evaluate Calls. At Scale.

Start Analyzing Free
See a Live Demo

Understanding Underperformance in Call Centers

Underperformance isn’t just a gut feeling; it’s quantifiable and observable. It manifests in two primary ways:

Quantitative Metrics (Key Performance Indicators – KPIs): These are the measurable indicators that reveal an agent’s efficiency and effectiveness.

  • Average Handle Time (AHT): If an agent consistently spends too long on calls, it can indicate inefficiency or knowledge gaps.
  • First Call Resolution (FCR): Low FCR rates suggest agents aren’t effectively resolving customer issues on the initial contact, leading to repeat calls.
  • Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) / Net Promoter Score (NPS): Poor scores here directly reflect customer dissatisfaction with an agent’s service.
  • Adherence to Schedule: Consistent lateness or early departures impact staffing levels and service availability.
  • Call Quality Scores: These scores, often derived from monitoring, highlight issues with soft skills, adherence to scripts, or information accuracy.
  • After-Call Work (ACW): Excessive time spent on ACW can point to inefficient processes or a lack of proficiency with tools.
  • Sales/Conversion Rates: For sales-focused centers, low conversion rates signal a need for improved sales techniques.

    Qualitative Observations:     Beyond the numbers, observable behaviors provide crucial insights into an agent’s performance.
  • Lack of empathy or poor customer soft skills.
  • Unclear or unprofessional communication.
  • Providing inaccurate or inconsistent information.
  • Frequent absenteeism or tardiness, disrupting team flow.
  • Resistance to coaching or feedback, hindering improvement.
  • Negative attitude or poor team collaboration, impacting morale.

Common Causes of Underperformance

Identifying the root cause is half the battle. Underperformance rarely stems from a single issue; it’s often a combination of factors.

Lack of Training/Knowledge Gaps: This can stem from inadequate initial onboarding or ongoing training, insufficient product, service, or policy knowledge, or a poor understanding or inefficient use of internal systems and tools.

Skill Deficiencies: Agents might struggle with weak communication skills, such as active listening, empathy, or de-escalation. They may also face difficulty with problem-solving or critical thinking under pressure, or demonstrate poor time management or organizational skills leading to inefficiency.

Motivational Issues: Factors like agent burnout or fatigue due to high stress and long hours can play a role. A lack of recognition, limited career growth opportunities, or insufficient engagement initiatives can also demotivate agents. Personal issues impacting focus and performance, or poor work-life balance, can contribute to disengagement.

Environmental/Systemic Factors: Sometimes, the environment itself is a culprit. This includes outdated or inefficient tools and technology, overwhelming call volume or a constantly stressful work environment, unclear expectations, inconsistent policies, or confusing procedures. Ineffective leadership or insufficient coaching from supervisors can also be significant systemic factors.

Components of a Call Center Action Plan Template

Here’s a detailed breakdown of the essential sections for your call center action plan template:

Section 1: Agent and Performance Information

This section sets the stage by providing all necessary background and context.

  • Agent Name & ID: For clear identification.
  • Supervisor Name: The person responsible for overseeing the plan.
  • Date of Plan Creation: When the plan was initiated.
  • Date of Last Review/Next Review: For tracking progress and scheduling follow-ups.
  • Performance Period Reviewed: Specify the timeframe from which the underperformance data was gathered (e.g., “last month’s performance data”).
  • Specific KPIs/Behaviors Identified as Underperforming: Detail the exact metrics and behaviors that require improvement, providing concrete data examples.
    • Example: “Agent’s Average Handle Time (AHT) is 450 seconds, exceeding the team target of 300 seconds.”
    • Example: “Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) score is 65%, significantly below the department target of 85%.”
    • Example: “Consistent use of unprofessional language observed in 3 out of 5 monitored calls this week.”

Section 2: Performance Goals (SMART Objectives)

This is where the desired outcomes are clearly articulated. It begins with an Overall Goal Statement, a concise, overarching declaration of what the agent needs to achieve. This is then broken down into Specific Goals with Target Metrics and Deadlines. Examples include, “Reduce AHT from 450 seconds to 350 seconds within 4 weeks,” “Improve CSAT score from 65% to 80% within 6 weeks, as measured by customer surveys,” or “Eliminate unprofessional language on 95% of calls monitored over the next 3 weeks.”

Section 3: Actionable Steps and Strategies

This is the “how-to” section, detailing the specific steps the agent and supervisor will take.

Training & Development Initiatives might involve completing specific online modules (e.g., “Complete ‘Empathy & Active Listening’ e-learning module by [Date]”), engaging in one-on-one coaching sessions (e.g., “Weekly 30-minute coaching sessions with Supervisor focusing on call flow and questioning techniques”), shadowing top-performing agents to learn best practices, or participating in role-playing exercises to practice challenging scenarios (e.g., “Daily 15-minute role-playing with supervisor on de-escalation”). Agents may also be directed to review specific knowledge base articles or internal wikis relevant to identified gaps.

Skill-Building Exercises could include practicing using communication scripts or templates, attending specific workshops on de-escalation techniques or effective probing questions, or implementing time management strategies (e.g., “Utilize call wrap-up codes efficiently and complete ACW within 60 seconds of call end”).

Resources Provided outlines the support offered, such as access to internal trainers or subject matter experts (SMEs), enrollment in specific online learning platforms or courses, or assignment of a peer mentor for ongoing support.

Crucially, Agent Commitments define what the agent explicitly agrees to do to achieve the goals. This includes actively participating in all coaching sessions and training, consciously applying learned techniques and feedback on calls, proactively seeking clarification from the supervisor or SMEs when unsure, and regularly reviewing knowledge base updates and policy changes.

Section 4: Monitoring and Review Plan

This section of the action plan details how an agent’s progress will be tracked and evaluated. It defines the frequency of check-ins (like daily, weekly, or bi-weekly), clearly states who is responsible for monitoring (e.g., the supervisor or QA team), and lists the data collection methods used (such as call monitoring scores, KPI dashboards, customer feedback, and agent self-assessments). Importantly, it also outlines a contingency plan for when goals aren’t met, which could involve further training or formal disciplinary actions.

Section 5: Signatures and Dates

Formalizing the agreement ensures accountability. This final section requires the Agent Signature acknowledging understanding and commitment, the Supervisor Signature acknowledging commitment to support and monitor, and the Date of Agreement, which marks the official start date of the action plan.

Implementation of the Call Center Action Plan Template

Having a well-designed template is only the first step. Effective implementation is key to success.

  • Initial Meeting and Communication: Conduct a private, supportive meeting. Present performance data objectively and explain the purpose of the action plan as a development tool. Emphasize partnership and the company’s commitment to the agent’s success.
  • Collaborative Goal Setting: Engage the agent actively in setting achievable goals and discussing specific actions. This fosters ownership.
  • Providing Resources and Support: Ensure the agent has immediate access to all training, tools, and support systems outlined in the plan. Offer ongoing encouragement and be readily available for questions.
  • Consistent Monitoring and Feedback: Adhere strictly to the established review schedule. Provide specific, actionable, and timely feedback – both constructive criticism and recognition for improvements. Celebrate even small wins to maintain motivation.
  • Adjusting the Plan: Be flexible. Performance improvement is not always linear. Be prepared to modify goals or strategies based on the agent’s progress and evolving needs.
  • Documentation: Maintain meticulous records of all meetings, coaching sessions, feedback provided, and performance data. This documentation is crucial for tracking progress and for any future HR discussions.

Best Practices for Maximizing Action Plan Effectiveness

To truly make your call center action plan example impactful, integrate these best practices:

  • Supervisor Training: Invest in training supervisors on effective coaching techniques, feedback delivery, and performance management. A skilled coach is pivotal.
  • Culture of Continuous Improvement: Foster an environment where learning, growth, and constructive feedback are embedded in the daily culture, not just reserved for underperformers.
  • Early Intervention: Address signs of underperformance promptly. The sooner issues are tackled, the easier they are to resolve before becoming ingrained habits.
  • Recognition and Reward: Acknowledge and reinforce positive changes and improvements. Recognition motivates agents to sustain their efforts.
  • Holistic Approach: Look beyond just the numbers. Consider all contributing factors to performance – personal, professional, and systemic – to offer comprehensive support.
  • Regular Template Review: Periodically assess and update your action plan template based on its effectiveness, agent feedback, and evolving business needs.

Conclusion

Implementing a structured and thoughtful action plan for underperforming call center agents is not merely a corrective measure; it’s a strategic investment in your most valuable asset: your people. A well-constructed call center action plan example can transform struggling agents into high performers, leading to tangible benefits like improved KPIs, enhanced customer satisfaction, increased agent retention, and a more engaged and motivated workforce. By committing to this structured approach, you’re not just fixing problems; you’re building a foundation for a consistently thriving and high-performing call center.

What’s the biggest challenge you face when trying to improve agent performance in your call center?